The Productivity Crisis – Part 2: Investment Inefficiency Decouples Skill And Value From Titles And Compensation

Author: John Oommen
Topics: Company purpose | Corporate strategy | Strategic planning

Executive Summary: Overstimulating the economy through easy money triggered a six-stage behavioral domino inside companies. A short-term focus on extrinsic market price over fundamentals fueled cost insensitivity, weak investment decision management, and unchecked hiring. Over-hiring led directly to title and pay inflation alongside the removal of objective performance assessments. Consequently, surface confidence outstripped tangible competence, decoupling skill and value from titles and compensation. Before attempting remedies, companies must self-assess against this sequence to dismantle superficial fixes, enact capital productivity, and embrace intrinsic value.

PUBLISHED ON JUNE 04, 2023
LAST UPDATED ON NOVEMBER 16, 2026
Complete read

In this second article of The Productivity Crisis series, we will discuss the domino of behavioral shifts that companies go through. As any meditation teacher would suggest, sitting with a deeper understanding of our reality is essential for solutions to stick. In the third article of The Productivity Crisis series, Rebuild Fundamentals With Investment Discipline And Human Capital Quality, we will discuss the measures companies can take to address productivity challenges.

Central banks have been struggling to keep a lid on inflation even with sharp interest rate increases because maintaining near-zero percentages for over a decade created systemically unsound consumer habits. After years of focusing on growth at the expense of earnings, companies initiated layoffs to show positive earnings. Regardless of these seemingly drastic actions, companies are starting to internalize that issues are deep-rooted: the more profound, systemic problem is The Productivity Crisis.

What is The Productivity Crisis?

Lots of running around, jumping from one activity to the next without finishing any of them, no time to sit down and think, preset plans tossed out the window, tantrums meeting the demand for discipline, and by the end of a super fun day, very little was accomplished from a grown-up perspective. These are my memories of spending quality time with my nieces and nephew. But it is understandable if it reminds you of an average corporate workday.

Significant outcomes are always predictable if we carefully observe the day-to-day behaviors of the players involved. We can forecast a sports team's likely trajectory through a season if we carefully follow its training sessions and locker room dynamics. How we operate our businesses to create value, and how we act when we buy (personally as consumers or professionally as employees), influences overarching outcomes. One such overarching outcome is productivity.

We use the word productivity often. All technology tools promise increased productivity, and everyone has easy access to productivity advice and optimal lifestyle habits. But results and objective measurements matter. To ensure objectivity, let's align on what productivity means. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) publishes productivity measurements often. Productivity measures our effectiveness in converting inputs to outputs.

BLS reports two key productivity metrics: Total Factor Productivity and Labor Productivity.

Let's start with Total Factor Productivity. According to BLS, it "compares the growth in output to the growth in a combination of inputs that include labor, capital, energy, materials, and services." Total Factor Productivity measures the efficiency of our overarching investment decisions.

In this definition, labor consists of people employed to perform tasks, while capital, energy, materials, and service investments are decided and managed by people. The simple conclusion that human decisions and actions are responsible for this measurement's absolute magnitude and growth is evident whichever way we slice this definition.

Now, what is Labor Productivity? Labor Productivity "compares the growth in output to the growth in hours worked." Labor is one of the five inputs of the Total Factor Productivity measure.

Data published by BLS for Total Factor Productivity and Labor Productivity growth reveals that productivity growth has been at its worst since 2007 compared to past decades, despite the impressive array of tools at our disposal. Both of these productivity metrics turned negative in recent years. In other words, we have been putting more inputs into the hopper and getting less output out.

Our first takeaway is that the annual growth rate of both Labor Productivity and Total Factor Productivity has declined since the 2008 Financial Crisis. Macroeconomic charts tell us why things look good to a casual observer while masking reality: we inject our economy with more inputs through monetary and fiscal policy, but the outputs we brandish do not reflect an increased ability to convert inputs to outputs.

Our second takeaway is that we disincentivized productivity by overstimulating our economy with inputs through easy money to increase output artificially. Our intrinsic ability to convert inputs to outputs isn’t improving despite significant investments, which is disappointing given all the advancements we believe we have made. 

This overarching outcome is how The Productivity Crisis is manifesting in our economy. Whether it is bank runs, overstaffing leading to layoffs, piling on debt to engineer unsustainable growth, or living with persistent inflation, the root cause is the inefficient conversion of inputs to outputs.

The Productivity Crisis has been predictable. In 2019, repeatedly observing early indicators of this crisis in the form of operational gaps at companies prompted me to document my evolutionary method as a book, Congruence: The Playmaker’s Guide to High Value Companies, which offers remedies for these structural challenges within companies.

Practical manifestation of The Productivity Crisis

Imagine getting to your gym for leg day at 6:00 PM. Your gym has three squat racks, and all three are occupied. You wait, only to observe the folks using the racks lift for 30 seconds and then browse their phones for the next five minutes. The gym invested capital in those racks, but the equipment is operating far below its potential productivity while you sit idle waiting for them to free up.

Now take this further: imagine you complain about the availability of squat racks, and management simply adds a fourth rack because the gym is flush with investor cash. You are happy, and you no longer feel rushed when using the equipment. Everything seems perfect. Correct?

In a practical sense, this illustrates The Productivity Crisis. Underutilized assets sit around most of the day, used inefficiently at personal convenience during peak hours. Dig deeper: someone had to manufacture those underutilized racks, someone cleans them, and someone else maintains them. All of this extra economic activity around the gym fails to improve baseline fitness levels. Therein lies our problem. Capital needs to be allocated to efficient pathways to serve society at a macro level. You can understand the drivers for this overarching incentive problem by exploring my resources about Capitalism and Duct Tape Economics.

In the micro construct of individual organizations, the dollars companies invest in human capital and fixed assets must seek far more productive avenues. With recent technological and information advances, flat or negative Total Factor Productivity growth is an operational failure.

We can look at the entire commercial ecosystem through the lens of companies because macroeconomic outcomes are simply an aggregation of the reality within individual organizations. Therefore, self-assessing our own work environments is essential.

How does The Productivity Crisis manifest inside companies?

Through persistent inflation, we are rediscovering that stable pricing is essential. The meaning of capital became spurious due to a prolonged easy-money era. Similarly, a cavalier attitude toward company design resulted in skill calibration challenges, which serve as the root cause behind economy-wide productivity challenges.

Many organizations are currently resorting to return-to-office protocols to address a gut feeling that productivity is low. But this is a blunt tactic analogous to an adrenaline shot: it provides a temporary wave of energy that wears off quickly and can even weaken the organization afterward. Each company must address its underlying conditioning and structural strength to tackle the crisis at its core.

Let's walk through the six-stage behavioral domino that results in an unproductive company. Self-assessing our organizations against this sequence is the necessary first step before attempting remedies. Without this level of introspection, companies will continue using superficial fixes, kicking the underlying problem further down the road.

Stage 1 of the Productivity Domino: Easy money incentivizes focus on extrinsic market price, not fundamentals

Governments routinely seek to prevent economic downturns at all costs, even when a correction is the appropriate capitalistic reality. Instead of enabling rational ground-level behavioral changes, policymakers rely on turbo-charged versions of past loose monetary and fiscal policies to keep perceptions of a healthy economy afloat. The Financial Crisis taught the world the wrong lesson: it conveyed that governments are always around like an overprotective helicopter parent to backstop bubbles and even predictable bad behavior. Every time market stress appears, central bank policy is adjusted to inject liquidity and artificially boost capital access.

However, these interventions fail to address the root cause of financial instability: Capital Engineering. As I detailed in Part 1 of The Productivity Crisis: Capital Engineering Distorts The True Intent of Capitalism, easy money leads directly back to structural failure. The Financial Crisis was caused by too much packaging, repackaging, and selling of paper assets around homes. Since then, we simply replaced homes with companies as the assets to trade, which is the root cause of ever-increasing public market prices of companies.

Immature businesses have been systematically over-priced because novel, unproven narratives are easy to market and sell. When refereeing disappears in a sport and one team begins fouling repeatedly without penalty, other teams follow suit. When immature companies maintain inflated paper share prices, even disciplined, long-term entities feel pressured to sacrifice operational rigor to boost short-term share prices or risk losing investor support. Barring a few exceptions, most companies have been forced to compromise on realizing value for customers in exchange for short-term financial measures of success that enable share price increases.

First Self-Assessment Question: How much focus does our organization place on unsustainable growth rates and extrinsic perceptions to inflate share price?

Stage 2 of the Productivity Domino: Short-term focus leads to cost insensitivity

Is a short-term focus inherently bad? Ensuring strong short-term outcomes is good management. But embellishing long-term prospects using short-term financial measures hurts companies, especially when those tactics are not supported by foundational maturity.

Short-term obsession with share prices distorts how we judge companies. Profitability is a necessity for an enterprise to remain viable. Yet in an easy-money ecosystem, share prices become tied to revenue velocity without regard for operating margin or underlying cost structure.

Imagine an advisor recommending an investment in a local coffee shop put up for sale. You walk by and see a shop packed with delighted customers. It looks like a fantastic business. Correct?

Now suppose the owner hired someone to stand outside handing out $5 bills to pedestrians on the condition that they walk inside, buy a $4 cup of coffee, and keep the remaining $1. Should that change your perspective on whether to invest?

Investors finance businesses operating on that exact coffee-shop logic throughout any easy-money era. When investors put capital into a business with an unsustainable unit economic model, they do so because a short-term exit option exists to pass the asset to the next buyer. When paper share prices remain high despite low fundamental maturity, cost insensitivity spreads across the entire economy like wildfire. This mindset bleeds into individual consumer habits, serving as the underlying driver of persistent inflation.

Cost insensitivity is precisely what an easy-money ecosystem encourages consumers, companies, and government institutions to embrace: spending. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) aggregates consumer, business, and government spending alongside net exports. In the US, internal spending accounts for over 100% of national GDP because net exports sit near negative 3%, meaning we borrow and spend capital as a country to buy goods from elsewhere.

Our narrow focus on propping up national GDP figures as a sign of economic health increases cost insensitivity across all sectors. Cost insensitivity translates directly to overspending money to generate less real value. This behavioral pattern leads directly to the third domino.

Second Self-Assessment Question: Does our organization prioritize growth at any cost without establishing operational maturity and unit-level profitability?

Stage 3 of the Productivity Domino: Investment decision management becomes weak

During an easy-money era, successful business outcomes are frequently an artifact of every competitor spending equally lavishly. But an artificial correlation between high expenditure and top-line growth does not imply causality. Under these conditions, the illusion that lavish spending is the root cause of good performance takes deep root across management teams. In short, management philosophy becomes anchored to the fallacy that positive outcomes will materialize regardless of the actual quality of investment decisions.

Consequently, our ability to connect realized outputs back to input decisions and actions degrades. This leads to organizations routinely bypassing rigorous investment analysis and effective decision-framing, attempting to generate short-term growth simply by overinvesting.

Spending authority spreads deeper into organizations, and the dollar thresholds individual managers can approve grow significantly. Meanwhile, the level of due diligence applied to capital allocation shrinks. Most ideas, including unvetted ones, receive approval. Purchasing technology solutions, expanding physical footprints, or acquiring smaller competitors become default decisions because cheap capital makes every group feel as if they have the Midas touch.

At the enterprise level, mergers and acquisitions surge. Yet leadership rarely conducts post-mortem reviews when an acquisition fails to deliver meaningful revenue expansion, product differentiation, or operational cost synergies. When poorly vetted initiatives fail to produce expected returns, organizations do not stop to ask "why." Instead, abundant liquidity incentivizes launching another under-vetted investment.

By failing to evaluate the ultimate return on invested capital, companies effectively remove consequences for poor allocation. Flawed investment decisions become standard operating practice, and the productivity of each invested dollar steadily declines.

Third Self-Assessment Question: How robust, objective, and accountable are our strategic and tactical investment decisions?

Stage 4 of the Productivity Domino: Poorly vetted human capital investment becomes pervasive

Every capital investment decision carries an implicit, long-term human labor commitment.

Executing mergers or divestitures requires teams of bankers, lawyers, consultants, and internal staff to source, close, and integrate assets. When operational friction arises, companies purchase off-the-shelf technology tools hoping for a quick fix. Yet deploying software requires internal administrators and implementation partners to run it. Similarly, every product line addition or geographic expansion demands continuous operational oversight.

Whether an organization invests directly in headcount, physical assets, technology stacks, or third-party services, it invariably hires additional labor to manage that investment. Hiring internal personnel or engaging external service providers becomes the default response to every operational problem and strategic objective. In a capital-inefficient domino, companies add headcount to force initiatives across the finish line without evaluating whether those initiatives have a viable path to success. Headcount expansion becomes an unregulated tap without an off switch in a cost-insensitive environment.

In a fundamentally mature ecosystem, management teams conduct the root cause problem-solving required to fix underlying operational issues rather than attempting to spend their way out of them. Squeezing more value out of existing investments, refining process design, and driving continuous operational improvements require minimal capital expenditure while solving root cause issues. Launching new high-cost initiatives is rarely the correct initial answer.

Because consequences for suboptimal decisions are minimal, an accountability gap emerges that drives economy-wide over-hiring. Though high-growth startups often initiate this trend, inflated paper share prices compel established enterprises across traditional industries to follow suit. Prior to an easy-money era, headcount additions required rigorous checks and balances. During loose monetary conditions, organizations dismantle those guardrails, making headcount growth a primary metric of organizational success.

However, the law of diminishing returns remains an inescapable reality.

Fourth Self-Assessment Question: Does loosened investment guardrails lead to an unregulated increase in internal headcount and external vendor spending across our organization?

Stage 5 of the Productivity Domino: Years of over-hiring lead to title and pay inflation

When an organization continuously expands headcount, new layers of management are required to oversee those new hires. When headcount increases exponentially, inexperienced employees are thrust into supervisory roles before building foundational operational competencies.

Staff members move from entry-level positions through multiple promotions within three or four years, by which point their direct reports manage teams of their own. Job titles inflate rapidly from individual contributor to manager, director, and vice president. As titles inflate to reflect authority, compensation scales alongside them, driving rapid labor cost increases.

When inexperienced employees receive rapid promotions and substantial salary increases, these benefits transform into systemic expectations. Title inflation and accelerated compensation become perceived rights rather than performance-based rewards.

Unchecked hiring frequently means filling vaguely defined roles with bodies. The rising volume of new hires results in rapidly promoted managers becoming primary decision-makers. This tactical hiring environment sidelines seasoned candidates with deeper expertise because high levels of competency often provoke insecurity among less experienced hiring managers. Favoring less experienced hires while sidelining seasoned players accelerates title and pay inflation among the former group at the expense of skill and competency across the company. 

This pattern brings about the final stage of the Productivity Domino.

Fifth Self-Assessment Question: Did fast-paced promotions and rapid compensation increases become a company-wide expectation simply to support expanding headcount?

Stage 6 of the Productivity Domino: Title inflation and removal of objective performance assessments lead to skill-to-role decoupling

Most professionals require time, deliberate practice, and mentorship to master a craft. Unsubstantiated career progression becomes an accepted corporate norm during an easy-money era, severely damaging organizational capability. Rapid advancement deprives individuals of the time required to build core skills.

Title inflation produces executives who never completed the operational apprenticeship necessary to internalize nuances of fundamental concepts. It becomes fashionable to define an executive's role merely as "hiring a team and letting them solve the problems."

An executive's primary job is to possess deep foundational expertise so they can coach, evaluate, and elevate their organization. Without that foundation, how can an executive distinguish between surface confidence and true competence? How can an inexperienced supervisor evaluate candidate skill or output quality?

When organizations approach hiring from a posture of fear – fear of missing targets due to open headcount, and fear of unfilled roles dominating executive discussions – performance management is dismantled or watered down into a check-the-box activity with little objectivity or accountability.

Consequently, skill decouples from job titles and compensation levels. Companies hire based on self-reported capabilities or candidate preferences rather than verified experience, core competencies, or demonstrated operational execution. This desperation grants individual candidates outsized leverage in the hiring process across nearly every sector.

Real-world examples of recent skill decoupling include:

  1. ‍“Product management” slide in the technology sector: Product management, originally a customer-centric, business problem-solving discipline, has morphed into an internally focused Agile-method-centric software development supervisory role. Companies began placing execution-focused software project managers into product management roles simply due to their proximity to software delivery. When a misaligned product manager expands their team, they hire for technical software development coordination rather than customer-centric problem-solving.‍
  2. Process design dilution: Process design is a science requiring business acumen and system thinking. It loses meaning when organizations attempt to plug software tools into broken workflows or take a superficial approach of documenting opinions as standard operating procedures, ignoring proven process fundamentals.‍
  3. Analytical rigor vs. data tooling: Companies routinely mistake the technical ability to build dashboards in tools like Tableau for true analytical capability. Analytical skill is characterized by structured problem-solving, hypothesis testing, and business acumen. Instead, organizations assign analytical responsibilities to tool operators, resulting in teams spending hours looking at attractive charts devoid of actionable decision-making insight.

When misaligned individual performers in pivotal roles are promoted to senior positions, skill dilution compounds. A skill-deficient executive hires and promotes based on criteria unrelated to skill. When companies place under-skilled leaders in senior positions, necessary strategic and operational evolution becomes inaccessible.

Sixth Self-Assessment Question: Did our organization dilute critical roles and resort to a bodies-in-seats staffing approach without prioritizing deep skill-building?

The reality behind the data

"Fake it till you make it" evolved from an adage into an accepted operating model. Surface confidence outstripped functional competence; talking about skills replaced building them. This decoupling of capability from job titles directly underpins our economy’s productivity and capital efficiency challenges.

During an easy-money cycle, candidate assessments grow lenient and biased against deep experience. Companies make hiring and promotion decisions based on superficial signals. While the phrase "It's not what you know, it's who you know" reflects an old corporate reality, past operational checks and balances kept skills and roles reasonably aligned. During periods of loose money, those guardrails are dismantled.

While human nature leans toward the easy path of managing perceptions over building capability, long-term market winners enforce capital productivity and generate intrinsic value.

Sit with this reality. Inspect your workplace. Does this six-stage domino reflect your experiences at one or more companies? We must remain objective about this systemic shift because its consequences impact our entire economy.

Author: John Oommen

Systems & First Principles Thinker | Playmaker | Author of Congruence

John Oommen is an electrical engineer turned company-level evolution architect who partners with private company investors and middle-market CEOs to mature and transform portfolio companies. He is the author of Congruence: The Playmaker's Guide to High Value Companies, creator of the underlying proprietary Congruence mindset, model, and method, and pioneer of the Playmaker Capability, which is a must-have value injection mechanism that dovetails purpose, strategy, and operations.

Over more than two decades, John has led company-level transformations, M&A integrations, and operational turnarounds across dozens of mid-market, VC and PE-backed, and Fortune 100 companies, including General Electric, Accenture, Blue Ridge Partners, and Capital One, as well as enterprise clients like Emerson, Ferguson, Cox, Avaya, and Nortek, alongside numerous mid-market companies. He specializes in addressing business-to-business market problems spanning industrial manufacturing, distribution, technology, and tech-enabled services. John holds an MBA from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management, is a certified Six Sigma Black Belt, and is based in Chicago.