The Productivity Crisis – Part 3: Rebuild Fundamentals With Investment Discipline And Human Capital Quality

Author: John Oommen
Topics: Company purpose | Corporate strategy | Strategic planning

Executive Summary: To overcome capital and operational productivity challenges, companies must adopt two levers. First, adopt a systemic opt-in investment mindset that rejects both overinvesting and reductive opt-out cost cutting. Anchored on corporate strategy and present operational reality, this forward-looking lever treats investment as a reward for achieving productivity and maturity rather than its cause. Second, optimize the quality of human capital investment by shifting from hiring volume to problem-solving, placing experienced decision-makers in executive and supervisor roles, improving operational design, and realigning roles with tangible skills.

PUBLISHED ON JUNE 21, 2023
UPDATED ON NOVEMBER 17, 2026
Complete read

We have a productivity problem, as I presented in the previous two articles in this series: The Productivity Crisis: Capital Engineering Distorts The True Intent of Capitalism and The Productivity Crisis: Investment Inefficiency Decouples Skill And Value From Titles And Compensation.

There are two levers that companies will have to adopt to improve their ecosystems' productivity. The first lever is a company's overarching investment philosophy. Is it an objective opt-in mindset? The second lever is the quality of its human capital investment. Keep the themes "too many cooks in the kitchen," "less is more," and "diminishing returns" in your mind as we explore these levers. Let's discuss how a company's choices on these two levers will impact the workforce and the company's overall trajectory.

The first lever: Adopt a systemic opt-in investment mindset.

We have already seen the Fed try to slow down the inflationary side effects of growth-at-any-cost conditions with interest rate hikes. Investors abandoned inflated market prices to some extent, and profitability is once again in focus. But profitability can be sustainable or unsustainable.

Companies invest more when monetary and fiscal policies are favorable and cut investment when macroeconomic factors turn sour. Typically, most companies are spending too much or cutting too much without independent and critical-thinking decisions underpinning those choices. The general implication of high or low investment is undifferentiated if treated as a single-directional blunt instrument as a reaction to good news or bad news, respectively.

Overinvesting is not an opt-in mindset.

Through the first two articles in this series, I articulated the easy-money-led investment behavior that triggered The Productivity Crisis. Regardless of macroeconomic conditions and incentives, when companies have money to spend, even if it's due to historical success, investment decisions tend to loosen.

Investing in growth increasingly becomes confident, and that confidence often surpasses the reality of the company’s operational maturity, which means the company is investing in diminishing returns. Functional executives build larger teams to sell more or market more with more layers of middle management. Investing in the latest tools, ideas, and even people becomes easy to approve even if it may not directly tie to what brought success to the company in the past.

Conversely, when a company is struggling from a customer or offering perspective, new investment can be poorly deployed into rinse-and-repeat ideas copied from other companies. Committing to new Hail Mary tactics feels easier than evaluating the root causes of the problems that customers are experiencing or causing operational inefficiencies, which effectively leads to overinvestment in low-ROI tactics.

Regardless of motivations, investing without robust foundations and rational due diligence is investing too much, and beyond one-off success stories, it usually proves to be an unproductive use of capital. 

Cost cutting is a reductive, “opt-out” investment mindset.

Conversely, many companies treat investment reduction decisions as a blunt lever solely to satisfy short-term financial metrics, especially when prior investments in rinse-and-repeat tactics backfire. What is the quickest way to improve earnings? Cut costs. For non-capital-intensive businesses, the easiest way to cut a massive share of cost is by cutting people. For capital-intensive businesses, this might be stopping spending on prior decisions to build or improve a physical asset.

Cost cutting is an opt-out investment mindset, which means one or more specific expense categories are lopped off when driven by external pressure or past investments do not pay off. This reactive mindset often hurts companies more than it helps because it is rarely executed with a One Company, systemic mindset.

More often than not, companies take the mindset of cutting off a limb to lose weight rather than putting in the miles to lose the unwanted pounds. Sooner than later, it backfires because the loss of limb causes greater immobility and access issues and results in bigger weight issues.

Additionally, most cost-cutting efforts are an about-turn as opposed to a brand-new objective decision. For instance, overhiring typically leads to cutting the people that were hired most recently, not a choice to keep the high performers and manage out low performers based on objective performance management. Such about-turn decisions only perpetuate prior cycles of poor investment decisions.

Capital allocation is rarely used as a proactive lever to improve behaviors, which is a significant missed opportunity.

An opt-in investment mindset is forward-looking and strategic.

Effective investment decisions are anchored on the company’s strategy and the present reality of its operations. As I frame in Congruence: The Playmaker’s Guide to High Value Companies, “strategic decisions are irreversible.” Investment decisions come from a company’s investment plan, which is part of a company’s strategic plan. Effective versions of these decisions are always looking into the future based on current reality and not looking backwards.

An opt-in mindset only invests in alignment with the company’s strategy and invests into mature operations, which imply productive behaviors across teams and employees. So it maximizes the probability and scale of positive outcomes because those decisions align with the company’s strategy and present operations baseline. 

Productivity is not a result of investment. Investment is a reward for achieving productivity and maturity.

For example, the CEO of a mid-market manufacturing company operating sustainably described his mindset as, "I don't set team-level spending budgets. My team wants me to give them carte blanche authority to choose projects and hire people. I want us to make rational situational decisions. It's not about the total spending, and I want to ensure I am not incentivizing my team to blow through a budget."

"We have money in the bank" and "I have a budget to spend this year" are government mindsets and not optimal for sustainable, profit-oriented companies. Effective company-level investment prioritization and decision-making constructs are a systemic necessity for sustainably growing and profitable companies.

First, commit to maturing the company’s approach to making future investment decisions. Every mid-market company must seek to reevaluate its corporate strategy each year in our ever-evolving world. Improving future decision-making starts with a cohesive and comprehensive corporate strategy and associated strategic plan, which sets a guardrail for every dollar the company invests. This limits the probability that the company is chasing suboptimal customers or attempting to create and deliver offerings well outside its wheelhouse.

Without such a single company-level strategy, the past overinvestment and cost-cutting cycles will continue to happen because the management team is guessing and hoping, not making robust decisions.

Second, we must look at all initiatives that have been green-lit at the company. Embrace a sustainable profitability mindset that leads from the company’s single strategy-led, operations-focused plan.

Vanity projects that do not tie directly to the necessary operational maturity and strategic direction of the company, but were previously approved as formal strategic initiatives, likely should not continue. If business integration efforts around mergers and acquisitions aren’t directly leading to creating value for the combined customer base or driving tangible operational synergies, they may not need to continue. Overeager geographic expansions that do not align with the One Company strategy will likely not result in a profitable revenue increase. Stopping the flow of good money into such past suboptimal choices is a necessary starting point. But this retrospective clean-up effort should not be treated as cost cutting; we are simply eliminating distractions that continue to take the company’s mindshare and investment dollars.

Third, beyond an effective strategy-led plan and elimination of misaligned investment choices, the productive execution of strategic initiatives and day-to-day operations requires proactively effective choices in the company’s strategic plan. Everything that happens in a company falls into either operating it in its present maturity or improving the fundamental maturity through major initiatives. All investment in a company goes into one of these two categories. 

An opt-in mindset implies that we intentionally only choose to invest in initiatives that improve operational maturity in line with strategy, and we only invest in operations so long as we execute with high maturity. Additionally, deploying capital with discipline instead of adding new investments at every turn characterizes maturity. Effective and objective decision-making structures and forums enable this maturity.

An opt-in investment mindset requires difficult choices.

A short-term escalation in involuntary job losses is a typical reality when an ecosystem moves to restore health and productivity. The benefit is that a broader adoption of investment efficiency reverses the pattern where workers jump around companies looking for increased pay and titles without an actual case behind those moves. Voluntary quitting decreases as more and more resources within the company align with meaningful efforts.

Due to our long-term overinvestment history, many companies lag in effective organization designs or objective performance management approaches. So, involuntary terminations will require maturity improvements around management approaches or risk subjective personnel decisions that eliminate skilled hard workers in lieu of individuals who may be better with workplace politics.

The sooner we accept that operating on steroids carries side effects that eventually catch up, the sooner we can rely on healthier habits to achieve outcomes. Adopting an opt-in mindset is hard. But to address skill and behavioral misalignments within a company, it must adopt a second lever to address productivity challenges.

The second lever: Optimize the quality of human capital investment.

When Mark Zuckerberg announced cutting 25% of Meta's workforce in 2023, he explained it as a "year of efficiency." What could Zuckerberg mean by efficiency? Simply put, it is a pivot away from the human capital investment behaviors of the last decade.

In the second article in this series, I explained the decoupling of job titles and seniority from skills and experience as one form of mutation that is triggering The Productivity Crisis. The solution to this decoupling is a painful realignment of human capital investment to value creation.

The Wall Street Journal recently reported that employee happiness jumped from 42% to 65% between 2010 and 2023. That is the highest figure since the 60s and worth celebrating. The primary reason for this fast rise in employee satisfaction is increasing pay and flexibility. Still, it has come at the expense of value creation. This contradiction with the productivity challenges we discussed makes this trend unsustainable.

Start-up investors often say, "We are investing in the founders." Simplistically, this translates to choosing founders with the best entrepreneurial traits. The same applies to how a company must invest in employees.

Align human capital investment to skills, experience, and competencies that create tangible value for customers and investors.

This second lever optimizes operational definition, organization design, hiring, performance management and promotions, and compensation to maximize value realized from human capital investment. These foundational aspects must align with the intrinsic value created by the company rather than perceptions of value.

The first step in deploying this lever is to shift the human capital investment mindset from focusing on the volume of hires to effective problem-solving. The days when executives and middle managers bank on adding new teams and staff or adding external contractors to address essential aspects of their roles are behind us. Executives and supervisors must shift their attention from staffing and hiring to problem-solving.

Translating information from customers, internal operations, and the market into optimal problem definitions and cost-effective and sustainable solutions is the correct measure of an effective supervisor or executive. Improving the value delivered using existing human capital investment, including coaching internal staff and measuring external service providers, is paramount. The skill to teach and upskill while possessing the experience to manage performance objectively is necessary.

The second step is tougher. Due to the title inflation trend of the past decade, we rapidly thrust many inexperienced individuals into executive and supervisor roles too quickly. The CEO and board must address executives and supervisors struggling to transition from the investment-heavy recent history into a problem-solving and investment-effectiveness ecosystem.

Optimization of a company's human capital investment requires the occupation of executive and supervisor roles with objective and experienced decision-makers and skilled problem solvers. It is also a better growth ecosystem for younger workers to receive coaching and mentorship from top-notch supervisors and executives. It is essential to refocus on meritocratic staffing if the company has a history of passing on skilled and experienced individuals based on age or other subtle biases.

In the GenAI world, executive and supervisory competency becomes even more important because they have to be competent and confident enough to delineate between “AI slop” and quality work products. People in these seats will have to differentiate between candidates with AI-generated resumes and cover letters and people with honest and substantial experience.

The first two steps are prerequisites to further a company's human capital investment agenda. When the experience and depth of expertise of executives and supervisors improve, so can the actual maturity of the organization. For instance, several employees at a company struggling with maturity after growing gangbusters told me that "we structure the organization to accommodate the people that have been here for a long time." An ecosystem where folks managing human capital investment focus on maintaining their positions stifles all other strategic and operational maturity efforts.

With a critical mass of effective problem-solvers and objective decision-makers in senior executive and supervisory roles, the third step can commence. In this third step, we must improve the operational design of the company. Maturity improvements in processes, including how the organization sells and delivers value to customers and uses data and technology, are a prerequisite to assessing human capital investment effectiveness. An adequate operational definition must precede organization design and underlying skill-based role definitions to ensure that human capital investment aligns with tangible value creation.

Once objective executives and supervisors with leadership skills and focus on fundamentally relevant topics are in place, creating efficient operational definitions and an organizational design is possible. We can glean gaps in skills and experience required for each role to create intrinsic value for internal or external customers from effective processes and organizational designs.

The fourth step is a complex transformation to elevate the skills and experience of roles framed in the optimized operational design. Employee roles will need to realign with tangible skills and knowledge. This step reverses the skill-to-role decoupling I described in the second essay in The Productivity Crisis series.

To sustainably optimize human capital investment, existing resources with enough competencies will have to upskill further to step into the well-defined, skill-based roles described in an optimized operations definition and organization design. Radical shifts such as role reassignments or terminations may become necessary for skill- or experience-mismatched employees in critical roles.

Imagine a marketing role at Company ABC. Anyone can search Google or ChatGPT with "give me a marketing approach" and export one or repurpose one from a prior employer that might look legitimate. But how does anyone know what 'good' looks like for a relevant and prescriptive marketing plan that takes Company ABC's specific growth stage and customers, product, and market conditions into account? All four steps above are pertinent to ensure that Company ABC's human capital investment has the appropriate skills and experience to create, assess, and deploy an effective marketing plan.

Organizations that embrace a sustainable growth mindset will objectively measure the competency and performance of resources in the context of the optimal operational design and organization design in step 3. Subjective assessments to cut staff without going through steps one, two, and three above are masking a short-term and reductive cost cut while calling it a skill- or performance-based cut.

Embracing this four-step human capital investment approach to increase focus on value creation and productivity will take time. More importantly, it will require clarity of vision from CEOs and their closest partners. Change is hard. The experience and objectivity of executives and critical supervisors will prove essential to making such a difficult transition stick.

Driving systemic changes where specific expectations are set for roles and objective measurements are used to monitor activities and interim outcomes will be a herculean change management effort. Executives with the clarity of vision and the grit to stand their ground on difficult decisions are prerequisites for such a transformation.

The next decade must be one of practicality rather than one of popularity to address our productivity challenges.

Only one of four pathways leads to investment effectiveness.

The 2-by-2 infographic embedded in the cover image highlights the four paths companies can take based on their choices for the two investment levers we discussed. Let's work our way up to the optimal path.

The least optimal is Path D, where a company isn't reading the writing on the wall. Here, a company avoids optimizing its overall investment approach and the quality of each dollar invested in human capital. Value-focused investors are not interested in institutions that operate frivolously. Path D would be ill-conceived with near-term ramifications for almost every institution. These two suboptimal choices will compound in a downward spiral resulting in financial and value creation challenges. Any institution hoping the economy will revert to the easy-money era is pursuing this suboptimal path.

It's hard to pick between Path B and Path C because both have significant pitfalls. Path C is a reversion to the company's recent past by placing capital constraints without improving the quality of the remaining investment in human capital. This path is cutting out recent investments in people and projects. Path C is only conceivable in the near term when the company has a very established core business that it is reverting to and away from recent poor investment decisions.

Path C is one of short-term financial viability and risks repeating the same investment mistakes in the future because the ecosystem's maturity is unlikely to have improved. Returning to the recent past implies sticking with decision-makers that made suboptimal choices that had to be reversed. It is worth asking, "What has changed?" Without improving the quality of human capital investment, overall investment effectiveness will prove problematic over time.

Path B is hard to pull off and is primarily motivated by a desire to avoid difficult decisions. Some companies have the cash and financial runway to avoid cutting costs for a while. In this path, the company attempts to mature its investment decisions and work through the maturity improvements discussed above. But the impact will be elusive. Imagine convincing a lifelong wealthy person to change their adult spending habits without removing access to family wealth. Changing those habits will require constraints. Total capital investment discipline via an opt-in mindset is necessary to improve productivity through higher-quality human capital investments.

Path A is the optimal one. It combines an opt-in mindset around total investment. It also ensures that every dollar of human capital investment maximizes sustainable value for customers and investors. It is the only path that balances the incentives of all stakeholders and financial sustainability, which are the core conditions of The Holistic Company model. An organization can radically increase the productivity of its investment in labor, capital, energy, materials, and purchased services through Path A.

Author: John Oommen

Systems & First Principles Thinker | Playmaker | Author of Congruence

John Oommen is an electrical engineer turned company-level evolution architect who partners with private company investors and middle-market CEOs to mature and transform portfolio companies. He is the author of Congruence: The Playmaker's Guide to High Value Companies, creator of the underlying proprietary Congruence mindset, model, and method, and pioneer of the Playmaker Capability, which is a must-have value injection mechanism that dovetails purpose, strategy, and operations.

Over more than two decades, John has led company-level transformations, M&A integrations, and operational turnarounds across dozens of mid-market, VC and PE-backed, and Fortune 100 companies, including General Electric, Accenture, Blue Ridge Partners, and Capital One, as well as enterprise clients like Emerson, Ferguson, Cox, Avaya, and Nortek, alongside numerous mid-market companies. He specializes in addressing business-to-business market problems spanning industrial manufacturing, distribution, technology, and tech-enabled services. John holds an MBA from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management, is a certified Six Sigma Black Belt, and is based in Chicago.